The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ Design of Sheet Pile Walls Engineer Manual from 1994 (EM 1110-2-2504 31 Mar 94) is unambiguous in its general preference of steel over concrete for sheet pile walls.
The following is a paragraph from Section 2-2:
“The designer must consider the possibility of material deterioration and its effect on the structural integrity of the system. Most permanent structures are constructed of steel or concrete. Concrete is capable of providing a long service life under normal circumstances but has relatively high initial costs when compared to steel sheet piling. They are more difficult to install than steel piling. Long-term field observations indicate that steel sheet piling provides a long service life when properly designed. Permanent installations should allow for subsequent installation of cathodic protection should excessive corrosion occur.”
Additionally, according to Recommendations of the Committee for Waterfront Structures Harbours and Waterways EAU 1996, “Steel sheet piling is frequently an ideal solution both as regards structural considerations and driving conditions, which is also capable of absorbing localised overloading without endangering overall stability” (Section 126.96.36.199, page 280).
Steel sheet piling systems also have the advantage over concrete in that they are a ready-to-use product delivered to the project, whereas concrete must be poured and cured at the job site.
Additionally, steel is environmentally friendly as it can be removed from a project or job site after service. Steel is also 100% recyclable.
Enter your wall dimensions and the values below will adjust automatically.
|retaining wall type||construction days||total cost||cost per linear ft||cost per square ft|
|Steel Sheet Pile Wall||47.69|
|Soldier Pile and Lagging Wall||90.45|
|Concrete Modular Unit Gravity Wall||76.18|
|Mechanically Stabilized Earth Wall||95.58|
|Cast-In-Place Reinforced Concrete Wall||136.09|
Approximate cost and construction time for different wall types is based on 2009 RSMeans pricing for the US and extrapolated from the 2009 NASSPA Retaining Wall Comparison Technical Report,
iSheetPile is a groundbreaking online tool to help you compare, configure, and map readily available steel sheet pile systems in a given market via their bending moment capacity in order to get the most efficient use of steel for your application.
Would you like our sales or technical support to provide you with more information?
To send us a message please use the contact request form to ask us about prices, technical questions, offer requests etc.
By using the form we will ensure that your message will be handled promptly. Our sales and technical people are dedicated to contact you within 24 hours of receiving your message and can give you a 1 on 1 tour of isheetpile.com, we can assist you in Spanish, Russian, German, Dutch, Mandarin and Japanese.
Or if this matter is urgent call us at +1.805.850.8500 during normal business hours in the United States.